Monday, November 16, 2026

The Logical Next Step: Recognising a Right to Counsel during Police Detention through Article 22

Article 22 of the Indian Constitution consists of two parts; the first enumerates rights guaranteed to persons detained through the regular criminal law (and spells out to whom the guarantees do not extend), and the second enumerates procedural safeguards for persons facing preventive detention. The contents of rights conferred by the first half of Article 22 are fairly unremarkable — no police detention beyond 24 hours unless reviewed by a judge, a right to be informed of the grounds of one's arrest, and to be defended by counsel of choice.

Over the past couple of years though, this unremarkable set of rights has emerged as a surprising site of judicial activity which has undeniably advanced the cause of individual liberty in Indian criminal law. This has primarily been through the largely consistent view adopted the Supreme Court, that a person must be furnished written grounds of their arrest, and a failure to do renders continued detention illegal. Together with this is the view (recently reiterated unequivocally) that the 24 hour limit on police custodial detention is triggered not with 'formal' arrest of a person but when the police have curtailed the liberty of a person de facto. A subsequent finding that the 24 hour rule was breached would render custody illegal and warrant release. 

This has made the first remand hearing before a magistrate an even more critical part of the process than before, given what is at stake. The magistrate is the first port of call, required to enforce Article 22. The problem with enforcing its rules about furnishing grounds of arrest and calculating a 24 hours is that the two concerned parties will almost always take opposing stands given what's at stake. The accused stands to secure bail if there is non-compliance, and police stands to obtain further custody in pursuit of a case. While there will be clear cases falling either way, there will also be many cases involving contestation around compliance with Article 22. Some of these will come with tricky allegations, heightening for a court the risks posed by a 'hyper-technical' adherence to the rule (discussed here).

How can we help the court in making the marginal calls? I think the root cause is how the criminal process currently structures this key interaction in the process. Right now, this is a face-off between police and the accused. What we need is a third person in the room, which can help the magistrate make a right decision. 

Existing legal rules do involve others in this process by prescribing a duty upon police to inform family members. This includes a statutory rule to inform family of one's arrest (in play since 2008), and recent judicial observations requiring communication of the grounds of such arrest to family members. Neither of these rules does the trick. A duty to inform family members about arrest does not help determine the start of detention to apply the 24 hour rule, because arrest is a formal procedure which, in many cases, happens only after a person has spent some hours in detention. The recent observations requiring communication of the grounds of arrest are not grounded in law and, in any event, do not ensure that the accused himself is shown and made to understand these grounds meaningfully.

A far better solution, one which almost all countries with rules prescribing limits upon police custody and detention have adopted, is to (a) create systems at police station allowing for independent verification, and (b) involving lawyers in this process to meaningfully assist the accused and not waste a court's time. 

The former is an issue which the Supreme Court has opined on, directing installation of CCTV cameras at police stations, both inside and outside. It is still struggling to secure enforcement almost six years after the direction was passed. With introduction of the BNSS, which now mandates video recording of police interactions, there is a great opportunity to link existing judicial directions and statutory provisions link them to Article 22. Having reliable, real-time footage would quell most doubts about when did detention begin and when grounds of arrest were conveyed. This alone, though, is obviously not enough to ensure compliance with the rules. First, because detention may not begin at a police station; second, because grounds may be conveyed but not understood by the accused person; third, because the CCTV may not work or might have gaps. This is where the lawyers come in.

It cannot be understated just how much of a shift having a legal professional would make to the dynamics of securing compliance with Article 22 from the perspective of all parties. If you are police, there is no real reason to object to the presence of a lawyer at this initial stage. Since police have to furnish written grounds already, having a lawyer present to meaningfully explain the grounds and confirm the detention duration helps avoid controversy at the remand hearing. If anything, a lawyer demanding written grounds is beneficial to police, by ensuring that they comply prior to the remand hearing. Nor does legal access not need for Article 22 purposes mean allowing access for the entire duration of the detention either and can be towards the end of an interview, giving police sufficient time to question a suspect in its custody. The benefit to the accused is obvious, though not as big as the benefit of having a lawyer present during questioning (This is something already regulated by statute so no point to argue there without asking for amendment). Perhaps the biggest benefit is to the remand magistrate, who has now been placed under even greater scrutiny with the recent re-emphasis around Article 22. A failure to comply with its rules means bail for an accused, which is the most important issue at the pre-trial stage. Conducting a remand hearing knowing that an accused already had access to a lawyer will give judges far greater confidence in believing the version of events being presented before them. It will also give greater confidence to appellate court judges before whom challenges may be filed later.

Extending a clear right to counsel for securing compliance Article 22 is the logical next step in the journey which the Supreme Court is undertaking at present. One hopes that it reaches this milestone sooner rather than later.                             

No comments:

Post a Comment