Showing posts with label Preventive Justice. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Preventive Justice. Show all posts

Friday, August 27, 2021

Rendering Criminal Law Meaningless: On the Draconian Telangana Preventive Detention Law

In 2017, the Telangana government passed a Bill to ratify and ordinance which had made the "Telangana Prevention of Dangerous Activities of Bootleggers, Dacoits, Drug-Offenders, Goondas, Immoral Traffic Offenders and Land-Grabbers Act 1986", into the "Telangana Prevention of Dangerous Activities of Bootleggers, Dacoits, Drug-Offenders, Goondas, Immoral Traffic Offenders, Land-Grabbers, Spurious Seed Offenders, Insecticide Offenders, Fertiliser Offenders, Food Adulteration Offenders, Fake Document Offenders, Scheduled Commodities Offenders, Forest Offenders, Gaming Offenders, Sexual Offenders, Explosive Substance Offenders, Arms Offenders, Cyber Crime Offenders, and White Collar or Financial Offenders Act 1986". The Centre had at first questioned this expansion — not due to any rights' concerns, but on grounds of legislative competence — but the President approved the act in 2018, leading to Act 13 of 2018 being passed by the Telangana government (with retrospective effect). Which gave us the Act. 

This preposterously named statute is not designed to create fast-track criminal courts for the many kinds of "offenders" it lists out in the title, or provide different rules on bail, or even reverse the onus of proof. Rather, this statute refers to categories of persons against whom the Telangana Government can exercise its powers of Preventive Detention. To understand what this process of Preventive Detention is all about, you should take the 4 minutes it takes to go through this wonderful set of illustrations by PenPencilDraw. 

Simply put, it is a process which enables police to jail people for up to 3 months at a stretch even if they have not committed a crime by a process which involves no proper judicial scrutiny of the allegations, and no right to counsel. What makes preventive detention even worse is that it is often used in tandem with the regular criminal justice system for offences allegedly committed by persons, where detention orders are passed when accused persons are pursuing bail applications or are just about to be released on bail. 

The expanded Telangana Preventive Detention Law is, in fact, seemingly designed to operate in this way. The various categories of "offenders" identified under the Act are defined in a way which expressly links them to the commission of different cognizable and non-bailable offences — for instance, "sexual offender" is defined as anyone who has committed or abetted commission of offences under Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act 2012, besides certain other Penal Code offences. If a person is accused of having committed such a crime, they will be arrested, and any "threat" to public order posed by them is therefore necessarily linked to their release, or potential release, on bail by a court.    

In this manner, the executive authority fully subverts the judicial process, sending the clear message that it does not matter whether a court applied its mind to a case and thought a person deserves to be released on bail - we can still keep her imprisoned.

When the Telangana Preventive Detention Law was recently involved in a case before the Supreme Court, the bench was surprised that it had not yet been challenged and called the law "draconian" [This was during the course of hearing and deciding Banka Sneha Sheela (Crl. Appeal No. 733 of 2021, decided on 02.08.2021)]. Preventive Detention, as I have argued elsewhere, is inherently draconian in a legal system which is based on the idea of a fair trial being necessary to impose severe sanctions of imprisonment upon anyone. Time and again, states which preach fidelity to this idea endorse Preventive Detention, relying upon that old friend called necessity. This argument acknowledges the need for Preventive Detention but, at the same time, also recognises the need for keep it confined to a domain of extraordinariness. 

By and large, it is fair to say that this has been the Indian approach, in theory, since the Constitution was passed in 1950. Which is what makes statutes such as the Telangana Preventive Detention Law so strikingly dissonant to the law, and so clearly draconian. I say statutes such as the Telangana law, because this is perhaps only the most egregious example from similar laws prevailing across states. And it is also apparent that other states have flirted with the idea of expanding the scope of their Preventive Detention laws in the past — Tamil Nadu, for instance, took a step back in 2014 considering an expansion would run afoul of the Constitution.

What Telangana has done with its Preventive Detention Law, and what other states have either wanted to do in the past and might yet do in the future, is to effectively render the criminal process redundant and in its place erect a crude system of speedy "justice" through jail time for persons "known" to be criminals. The Supreme Court has said that it is cannot be a quick alternative to the regular criminal process, but honestly, that is what Preventive Detention is today. And in a criminal process plagued by delays at every level, it is easy to understand why there is an acceptance for such measures within the government, if not also within society at large. 

Sure, a state government may suffer the odd rap on the knuckles in court for adopting tactics where such obvious deprivation of rights is involved. But on a balance of considerations, is that not worth the cost when what the government stands to gain is a reduction in the crime rate. Want to curb spurious seed sales? Bring it under Preventive Detention. Want to show a tough stance on sexual offences? Bring that also under Preventive Detention. Same for cyber crime, rave parties, and any other kind of undesirable activity you can find. 

Is not the deprivation of liberty for a few justified when it leads to the improvement in the quality of life for the many? This is a false equivalence if there ever was one — this relationship between crime rates and Preventive Detention is no scientifically identified cause and effect but the police crediting any measure they like after the data comes in. It is obvious that they will credit measures which confer upon them almost boundless power and take away the "hassle" of criminal procedure. But the problem is that this false equivalence sells and is easy to fall for. Which is why more states are likely to go down the Telangana route in the future, I suspect, as it is unlikely that any of them are going to actually make the kind of investment required to actually improve how the criminal process functions.

The Telangana Preventive Detention Law might yet be successfully challenged in court and trimmed down to size, but until the criminal process begins to assume some degree of speed, the attractions of "doing justice" through Preventive Detention will remain very high for governments. 

Wednesday, September 2, 2020

Dr. Kafeel Khan and Our Punitive Preventive Detention Law

On August 11, the Supreme Court had requested the Allahabad High Court to expeditiously decide the habeas corpus petition filed by Nuzhat Perween for her son, Dr. Kafeel Khan. The petition challenged orders for his preventive detention under the National Security Act of 1980 (NSA) that were passed on February 13, 2020. Initially filed before the Supreme Court in February itself, the petition was sent to the Allahabad High Court in March, where it was heard multiple times before, finally, a Two Judges’ Bench passed a judgment on 01.09.2020 in Nuzhat Perween v. State of UP and Anr., [Habeas Corpus WP No. 264 of 2020 (decided on 01.09.2020)] declaring the detention order illegal and directing Dr. Khan’s immediate release. 

Unlike the last time that a judicial authority directed his release on 10.02.2020, following which Dr. Khan was not released but instead led to the impugned detention order being passed, this time Dr. Khan has indeed stepped out of prison and as of now has not been arrested in any other proceedings.

Background to the Preventive Detention
Dr. Khan’s prevention detention under the NSA is only the most recent episode of the state machinery training its attention on him and depriving him of his personal liberty, only for a judicial authority to direct his release. 

According to the state, what prompted the order on 13.02.2020 was a public speech given by Dr. Khan in Aligarh to a group of students on 12.12.2019, an event more than two months old. It was stated that the speech incited feelings of communal disharmony and also lent itself to violent protests by groups of students on 13th and 15th December in Aligarh District. The proposal for preventive detention, made on the same date as the order, stated that “Since the fierce and communal speech given by him has had an adverse and unfavourable impact on the public order of the District, therefore it is very important to keep this person detained in jail to maintain the public order. (emphasis mine)”

Take a close look at the last line above — preventive detention was necessary to keep Dr. Khan in jail. Why was he in jail, you ask? Because following the speech of 12.12.2019, a case was registered at P.S. Civil Lines, Aligarh, in the early hours of 13.12.2019 alleging inter alia that the speech incites communal disharmony. Dr. Khan was not immediately arrested in this case, but was ultimately taken into custody from Mumbai on 29.01.2020. He filed for bail, a request which was naturally opposed by the state. Despite the opposition, however, bail was granted on 10.02.2020. Two observations in the bail order are important: first, the Court rebuffed the state claim about the accused repeating the offence by stating that this would be grounds to challenge his bail, and; second, the court placed a bail condition upon Dr. Khan to “ not repeat the crime in the future”.

What happened next is in keeping with the worst traditions of how governments run in our republic, witnessed from the days of A.K. Gopalan itself (no, not his Supreme Court case). The bail order was passed but not given effect to by the executive. Two days later, on 13.02.2020, the trial court passed another order directing jail authorities to release Dr. Khan and directed its delivery by Special Messenger. However, the state claimed this was only received at 8:20 PM in the evening, by which time the preventive detention order had been proposed by the Officer in Charge of PS Civil Lines, sponsored by the Deputy Inspector General of Police, and authorised by the District Magistrate, Aligarh.

Therefore, it would be a mistake to think that Dr. Khan’s preventive detention was specifically required because of the incident of December, 2019. Rather, the need was only perceived by the U.P. Government once a competent court had applied its mind to the allegations against Dr. Khan in the regular course of law, and found that there was no reason to prolong his pre-trial custody any further. 

The Allahabad High Court Verdict
Before proceeding to the order that came to be passed in the habeas corpus petition, it must be mentioned that it took close to six months for a decision to be made in the matter. Even if we exclude the time the petition was in the Supreme Court, it is still an inordinate delay for what is arguably the most crucial kind of case before courts — one directly concerning the liberty of a citizen. 

Having said that, the short judgment of 42 pages does not waste too much time in getting down to the matter. The petition challenged the order of 13.02.2020 on three broad prongs: (i) there was no material for ordering preventive detention and it was intended to subvert the judicial process; (ii) the detenue was not supplied with all material thus denied a right to file an effective representation against his detention, and; (iii) the concerned government had unduly delayed the consideration of his representation against detention. I will only focus on (i) and (ii), as the judgment is restricted to a consideration of only these grounds. On both these legal issues, the Allahabad High Court has made some important observations.

Supplying Material
Let’s look at (ii) first because this is a small point. The High Court noted that while Dr. Khan had been given a CD with the speech ascribed to him, he was not given any means to play this disc. Neither was he supplied with any transcript of this speech, which was the primary basis for his preventive detention. This was unconscionable, and the Court rightly held it so, finding that this conduct on part of the state government deprived the detenue of his constitutional right to make an effective representation against his detention. 

Preventive Detention and Subjective Satisfaction
The Allahabad High Court was asked to consider the contents of the speech given by Dr. Khan in December 2019 to decide whether a reasonable person could apprehend any disturbance to public order based on his exhortations. The Court’s approach in this regard is important and requires a brief excursus to explain the legal position on how challenges to preventive detention orders are to be treated by the judiciary.

The law on preventive detention is an executive-driven process: it is an extraordinary power that executive officials in India have to make sure that imminent threats to public disorder etc. can be addressed swiftly without going through the rigour of the regular criminal process. The primacy given to the executive requires that in any subsequent challenge to a detention order, judges cannot substitute their mind for the subjective satisfaction of the executive official who made the decision in the heat of the moment. The judge cannot place herself in the shoes of the police officer. 

At the same time, however, this doctrine of respecting the subjective satisfaction of executive officials is not a license for abdicating the judicial function entirely when considering a challenge to preventive detention. Courts must still apprise themselves of the materials presented before the detaining authority to decide if the decision to authorise preventive detention was arbitrary and unreasonable. There is no running away from the fact that the lines being drawn here are fuzzy, and while it moves some courts to be excessively deferential to the executive, it equally allows other courts to keenly consider the facts without overstepping the limits of the judicial function or abdicating it entirely. 

In Nuzhat Perween, the Allahabad High Court clearly took the latter approach: 

“We are in absolute agreement with learned Additional Advocate General that it is not open for the courts to substitute their opinion by interfering with “subjective satisfaction of the detaining authority”. However, it does not mean that the court cannot look into the material on which detention is based. The expression “subjective satisfaction” means the satisfaction of a reasonable man that can be arrived at on the basis of some material which satisfies a rational man. It does not refer to whim or caprice of the authority concerned. While assessing “subjective satisfaction of the detaining authority” the Court examining a petition seeking a writ of habeas corpus has to look into the record to examine whether the subjective satisfaction is acceptable to a reasonable wisdom and that satisfies rationality of normal thinking and analyzing process. … In view of above, we have looked into the speech delivered by the detenue. The closure of examining record as suggested would be nothing but a licence to allow the executives to act at their whims or caprice. This would be against the fundamentals of our constitutional values and provisions. (Emphasis Mine)”

In line with this approach, the High Court looked at materials forming the basis for the detention order in detail. The judgment quotes the entirety of Dr. Khan’s 23 minute-long speech made on December 12, to demonstrate how the police requests for preventive detention in this case had, in fact, not presented the authority with the complete picture. Instead, the police had patched up different parts of Dr. Khan's speech to present a different picture altogether from what appeared to be the speaker’s intention. It held, therefore, that based on this material it was impossible to conclude that Dr. Khan’s activities were such as to prejudice the maintenance of public order. 


Punitive Preventive Detention
The peculiar facts leading up to the detention order of 13.02.2020 have been extracted above, and it was argued that this demonstrates that the two months’ delay in passing the order, and its expeditious authorisation after Dr. Khan’s bail, all went to show that the preventive detention order was actuated by malice and not based on any genuine grounds. 

This is a more tedious issue than what might appear at first blush. It is because the Supreme Court has held, on countless occasions, that it is not illegal to pass a preventive detention order in cases where the person is already in custody and about to be released on bail. Most recently, this was confirmed by the Court in Dimple Happy Dhakad [AIR 2019 SC 3428] (Discussed on this Blog as well). Technically then, preventing Dr. Khan’s release on bail was a legally valid ground for the U.P. Government to take. 

This is really the twilight zone when it comes to preventive detention, where the preventive setup inextricably merges with the regular criminal process. The only justifiable premise for passing a preventive detention order in respect of a person who is about to be released on bail is if the authority can demonstrate that there is a continuing threat which did not dissipate once the regular criminal process has taken charge of the matter. This is not unimaginable — organised crime has many stories of rackets being run from prison. But it must be a very hard sell for the executive and it cannot be a means to pile-on incarceration upon persons deemed undesirable by the state. Not only would such delayed preventive detention orders turn the concept on its head — where is the prevention if the person was already in jail for months after the incident! — but it would also directly subvert the determination made by a competent court that there was no need for a person’s continued incarceration. At a macro-level, repeat occurrences of this phenomenon place an undeniable strain upon the relationship between the executive and judiciary, and give rise to an unconstitutional chimera of punitive preventive detention that hollows out the right to personal liberty from within. 

This is why courts must arguably be more vigilant while entertaining challenges to preventive detention orders in such cases where bail order is passed and, in some way, circumvented — as the Supreme Court has also emphasised on some occasions in the past. This is exactly the kind of approach on display in Nuzhat Perween, where the Allahabad High Court noted that:


“The exact nature of the contents of the lecture delivered by the detenue on 12.12.2019 at the Bab-e-Syed Gate of the AMU (as claimed by the state authorities), even if accepted to be correct, it cannot be overlooked that, that material could not be relevant for the purpose of satisfaction being drawn two months thereafter, inasmuch during that period of two months, undisputedly, the detenue neither visited the city of Aligarh nor he made any further or other speech or lecture connected thereto nor there is any material shown to us that the detenue was about to commit any act in furtherance thereto or was going to deliver any other speech or lecture connected thereto as may have prejudiced the public order.”

There was no fresh alleged illegal activity between December and February which prompted the order of 13.02.2020, even though Dr. Khan had been at liberty throughout that time. There was not even a proposal to pass an order for his preventive detention in that period. The first time when the idea came to the government was after the bail order was passed. For the Court, all this pointed to a conclusion that the gap of two months’ snapped whatever link existed between the allegedly offending conduct of Dr. Khan with a need to require his preventive detention. 

Our Slow-Moving Wheels of Justice 
The story of Dr. Khan and the manner in which the preventive detention machinery was clearly misused by the state government to keep a dissident behind bars is a tale as old as time itself. Small wonder why the writ of habeas corpus has such a celebrated position in societies. Indian courts have not had the most shining of records in terms of processing habeas petitions over the past few years and the delay that it took for Dr. Khan’s petition to be heard speaks to this serious systemic problem. But, ultimately, a court did apply its mind, and restore a person's liberty. 

The episode reminds me of a scene from the movie Shahid, where the young, imprisoned, Shahid Azmi is told by War Saab (played by KK Menon) that the wheels of justice turn slowly in India, but they do eventually turn.

Well, eventually, I guess they do.

Wednesday, September 18, 2019

Preventive Detention: Article Update

(This is an article update for new scholarship and not a substantive post. The paper is available here)

Since August 5, the rest of India has been cut-off from the happenings in the (erstwhile) State of Jammu and Kashmir, except when the happenings are released at the convenience of those in power. Thus, today, we find ourselves in the remarkable situation, that even after almost 45 days, the rest of India remains unaware of the legal basis for the untrammelled show of executive discretion currently on display in various parts of Kashmir. A situation which the Supreme Court is aware of, and yet, has taken no steps to remedy either.

The eerie silence around Kashmir has also, reportedly, been brought about through widespread arrests and detentions — again, the basis for which has not been made public to the rest of us. It is probable, that a large number of these arrests have been carried out by the police using powers of what is called "Preventive Detention". But it would be a misnomer to continue calling it this, considering that it is rarely only used for preventive purposes. So I'll call it by another name by which it is known in other parts of the world: Executive Detention.

What, then, is Executive Detention? As the name suggests, this is a denial of liberty carried out by the Executive, and only the Executive, without any worthwhile judicial supervision. A Commissioner of Police can order the arrest of any person on suspicion of doing acts prejudicial to "public order" or other vague / strange grounds, without giving any reasons upon arrest, and detain persons for upto ninety days without judicial scrutiny. The law allows police to arrest first and seek approval for this detention, which only involves scrutiny by senior executive officers. Of course, the person can make a representation against this arrest and detention, but she is denied the right to counsel. And, if a non-judicial body approves, the detention can also last upto one year or more.

There is the regular outrage when Executive Detention is used by governments for, seemingly, jailing political opponents or trampling upon civil liberties. But, amidst all this, there is surprisingly little critique about the set of legal regulations that primarily governs all legislation on the subject of Executive Detention in India: Article 22 of the Constitution itself. Through Articles 22(3) to (7), the Constitution prescribes a set of do's and don'ts that the Executive Detention laws must comply with. And my description of such laws in the preceding paragraph is fully constitutional. 

The shortcomings of the legal minima prescribed by the Constitution are many. Not only were these baselines extremely generous to the Executive when compared with other existing legal positions in 1950 itself, but over time, the continuance of these baselines has created a strange duality in the law. While the judiciary has expanded the protections for individual liberty in most spheres of law, it has not been able to do so in the sphere that requires these protections the most. All of which has led to a reality where, over the years, successive governments have gradually turned the supposedly extreme measure of Executive Detention into just another law enforcement tool, by passing laws that only barely pass the already low-lying constitutional threshold. 

If that strikes your conscience, even the tiniest bit, then ask yourself: Why do we persist with this set of legal standards that maximise executive discretion to ensure public safety but by nullifying individual liberty to absurd levels? Can we not reconfigure the attempts at striking a balance between these apparently conflicting interests that the framers of the Constitution made? If we have done this for many other parts of the Constitution, noting that times change, then why not this part which  goes to the root of the Constitutions' ambition of creating a legal order that safeguards individual liberty?

In a short paper, I've tried to initiate this conversation around Article 22 of the Constitution. I strongly think that the persistence of these clauses is a blot upon the Constitution, in more ways than one, and it is no answer to say that we must live with the status quo  simply because the Constituent Assembly had brought this Article to life. This ritualising goes against the very idea of a social contract between Citizen and State, which imagines that future generations are not bound by the choices of their predecessors. It is high time we begin the discussion to reconsider the choices made by the Framers of the Constitution to place the "interests of the state" high above the "exigency of liberty of the individual". 

P.S.: I must not be mistaken to say that the choices of the past can be thrust aside by the tyranny of a majority or executive supremacy. Discussion, not imposition, is the means towards a new set of laws in a democratic republic.  

Tuesday, December 25, 2018

Guest Post: Arrests Under the Infamous ‘No Vakil, No Appeal, No Daleel’ Law

(I am happy to host a guest post by Ms. Aasavri Rai, a final year student of the B.A. LL.B. (Hons.) Program at National Law University Delhi)

The National Security Act, or as it is (un)popularly called the "no vakil, no appeal, no daleel" law, became effective from 27th December 1980, pursuant to a National Security Ordinance which was introduced by the then Prime Minister Indira Gandhi. The Ordinance promulgated on 23rd September 1980 was originally meant to "deal with black marketeers, smugglers and anti-social elements, and not to end civil liberties". Even in this brief period of three months, over 730 arrests (excluding figures from Punjab and North-East) were made under the Ordinance. These arrests did not target a single smuggler or black-marketeer; instead, well-known political activists and trade unionists were hauled up by the government. One such name was that of trade unionist AK Roy, whose writ petition, along with others, was heard by a Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court in 1981. 

This disturbing trend has been exacerbated through the years, as the NSA has been used freely with little regard to the original purpose of this preventive detention legislation. The Act is employed as a weapon to stifle political dissent. Uttar Pradesh has seen glaring misuse of the statute with over 160 arrests being reported in January 2018. The arrest and re-arrest of a journalist who criticised the Prime Minister in a social media post, a Krishak Mukti Sangram Samiti leader’s re-arrest ahead of Amit Shah’s visit, and Bhim Army chief’s arrest under the Act, a day after acceptance of his bail petition, are other disturbing instances of the misuse of the Act. 

The exceedingly broad and open-ended grounds of detention have resulted in a widespread misuse of the Act. In this post, it is argued that the grounds for detention under Section 3 are vague, disjunctive and thereby have a low threshold, and are determined as per the subjective determination of the detaining authority, which is shielded from judicial review. 

Vagueness under Section 3 of the NSA
What are the grounds detailed under Section 3 of the NSA? Section 3(1)(a) of the Act tells us that orders for preventive detention can be issued in respect of any person, to prevent them from "acting in any manner prejudicial" to (i) the defence of India, (ii) India's relations with foreign powers, or (iii) India's security. Foreigners can also be subjected to preventive detention to regulate their continued presence in India or towards making arrangements for their expulsion [Section 3(1)(b)]. 

These were new grounds, and at least hypothetically speaking, limited. But the same cannot be said for the next set of grounds that follow in Section 3(2): preventive detention orders are possible to safeguard the (i) security of the State, (ii) maintenance of public order, or (iii) maintenance of supplies and services essential to the community. These were the grounds on which both central and state preventive detention legislation had been operating in the three decades of India's history as a republic. 

The challenge in AK Roy was to both sets of grounds, where petitioners argued that these were vague. It harked back to the customary international law principle of legality, that seeks to curb uncertainty and arbitrariness in law through vague and imprecise definitions. The Supreme Court agreed that the problem of vagueness is grave, but found that there was no problem in this case. Not because it gave us a concrete interpretation, but instead, as the controlling opinion noted, "formulation of definitions cannot be a panacea to the evil of vagueness and uncertainty". In doing so, it relied on the existing judicial engagement with Section 3(2) style grounds where the Supreme Court had consistently held that the vagueness was necessary. 

I argue that this was incorrect. While there was an extensive body of law on preventive detention, an uncritical application of the same was uncalled for. Largely because there was a watershed moment in this time: the re-insertion of due process requirements through the Bank Nationalisation and Maneka Gandhi decisions. These decisions supported an argument against vagueness and uncertainty in a much broader fashion than the pre-existing position. However, while the Court in AK Roy did not fail to cite Maneka Gandhi, it was incorrect in thinking that the decision did not prevent reliance on the pre-existing case law. 

The Court in AK Roy had an alternate path. Even if it was committed to saving the NSA - to avoid the wrath of the same Government that brought about the Emergency - it could have faithfully applied the stricter standards of judicial review that Bank Nationalisation and Maneka Gandhi offered and then built upon the existing law, where through decisions such as Romesh Thappar, Brijbhushan v State of Delhi, and Ram Manohar Lohia, the Court had in fact given guidance on how to interpret vague terms like public order. Instead, the Supreme Court went into full deference mode, and did not even attempt to venture into possible interpretations of the array of grounds provided under Section 3 NSA. 

This wide discretion in interpretation of the grounds for detention has led to an alarming increase in the instances of arrests in recent times. In Uttar Pradesh, 81 people were preventively detained after violence broke out in Kasganj, pursuant to which the DGP quoted that the NSA will be invoked against "criminals (emphasis mine) for vitiating the atmosphere". After 51 people were arrested for cheating on an exam, UP CM Yogi Adityanath directed the investigating agencies to slap NSA provisions, to ensure "transparent and corruption free" examinations. Arrests have also been made for brawls during neighbourhood cricket matches, allegedly carrying beef, and uploading videos on Facebook criticising the Prime Minister. Children of multiple detenus have faced ostracisation at their school, for their fathers being ‘criminals’. 

By no means is the vagueness of grounds under Section 3 the sole reason for calling the NSA a draconian law. Other notable features include the disjunctive requirement of satisfying the grounds, i.e., an order passed on many grounds can't be set aside unless all of the grounds are found to be bad. Together with this is the principle that courts cannot question the subjective satisfaction of executive officers who passed detention orders. But it should be clear that the vagueness issue greatly enhances the problematic nature of these other features. After all, it is the core of the NSA, and if the core is rotten, all else follows.

Conclusion 
Preventive detention laws have found a place in the Indian legal system since the colonial era. Unsurprisingly, these legislations continue to be used to curb individual liberty and stifle dissent. The consequences of such statutes have historically proven to be dangerously repressive. The same can be witnessed at present where even trivial disturbances are being accorded the status of national security concerns. The idea behind preventive detention statutes is to detain people based on their previous conduct and the apprehension that they might engage in similar conduct in the future. The recent barrage of cases under the NSA has been against people with no previous history of misconduct. The cherry on the cake is the branding of the detenus as ‘criminals’, with the presumption of innocence being conveniently done away with. 

These instances also highlight the disturbing trend of the NSA being used as a tool to keep certain people behind bars. If criminal cases are pending against the accused and the accused is granted bail, almost immediately NSA charges are slapped to send her away again. In most such cases, the order of extension of the detention is arbitrary and the grounds are not conveyed to the detenu and her family members. Even though Section 13 of the Act provides for a twelve-month period, as noted in AK Roy, such a time duration is the maximum period of detention possible, and the detaining authorities are at the liberty to modify the order of detention and reduce the term. However, such a reduction of the period of detention is rarely ever witnessed in practice. The majority of these cases also reek of the biased and discriminatory policies of the administration, as most of the detenus are Muslims, people belonging to the Scheduled Castes, or the poor. While the Court had the ability to do away with the draconian provisions of the Act in AK Roy, it comfortably expressed its inability to derogate from the Constitutional provisions and expressed regret for doing the same. Though the Court does throw in certain observations to pacify the citizens, even these minimum possible protections aren’t being provided to the detenus.

Friday, December 30, 2016

Preventive Justice Part 3 - An Overview of the Statutes

The two previous posts in the Preventive Justice series focused on Article 22 of the Indian Constitution which prescribes basic minimums regarding preventive detention in India. The history behind this constitutional provision - labelled an anachronism - offers further support to that old adage of not judging books by their covers. The development of due process law in India was used to question the sustainability of the basic minimums constitutionally prescribed by Article 22. To recap, it was argued that the Supreme Court has, unambiguously, held that Article 22 is not a complete code and preventive detention laws are open to challenge under Articles 19 and 21. In this concluding post in the series, I look at the many statutes - both federal and state - in India that authorise preventive detention for a wide variety of acts. The question I beg, not always directly, is whether these would pass muster when tested against Articles 19, 21 and 22 of the Constitution. 

Scope of Legislative Power on Preventive Detention
The Seventh Schedule to the Indian Constitution details the various items on which the federal and state legislatures can pass laws. Preventive Detention figures as Entry 9 on the Federal List (List I) as well as Entry 3 of the Concurrent List (List III). These read as follows:

Entry 9, List I: Preventive detention for reasons connected with Defence, Foreign Affairs, or the security of India; persons subjected to such detention.

Entry 3, List III: Preventive detention for reasons connected with security of a State, the maintenance of public order, or the maintenance of supplies and services essential to the community; persons subjected to such detention.

In A.K. Gopalan v State of Madras [AIR 1950 SC 27] the majority held there was no requirement to specify what issue of defence or foreign affairs a preventive detention statute sought to deal with. It would be legal for it to simply refer to the subjects mentioned in these entries as justifications. As we shall see, this proved to be important for courts in upholding the validity of these statutes.

Federal Laws Authorising Preventive Detention
Is it purely coincidental that the federal laws authorising preventive detention in India today have some connection with the 1975 Emergency, when preventive detentions were most routinely ordered? Perhaps. Although the controversial Maintenance of Internal Security Act, 1971 was repealed in 1978, its cousin the Conservation of Foreign Exchange and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974 (COFEPOSA) was not. This was, in fact, supplemented by the National Security Act (NSA) and the Prevention of Black Marketing and Maintenance of Supplies of Essential Commodities Act (Black Marketing Act) in 1980. What are the purposes of these laws and what do they proscribe?
  • COFEPOSA: Allows for preventive detention for "conservation and augmentation of foreign exchange and prevention of smuggling activities." 
  • NSA: Persons acting "prejudicial to the defence of India, the relations of India with foreign powers, or the security of India" as well as those acting "prejudicial to the security of a State, the maintenance of public order, or the maintenance of supplies and services essential to the community can be preventively detained.
  • Black Marketing Act: Allows for detention in cases for prevention of "blackmarketing and maintenance of supplies of commodities essential to the community."
Do these objectives fall foul of the tests laid down in Articles 19, 21 and 22? The legality of the NSA was challenged in A.K. Roy v Union of India [AIR 1982 SC 710], and upheld by the Supreme Court. It helped that the legislature had copied the objectives from the Seventh Schedule. 

The COFEPOSA posed a more interesting challenge. Passed before the Emergency, it was also placed in the Ninth Schedule. This was the basis for the Supreme Court upholding its validity in Attorney General for India v Amratlal Prajivandas [AIR 1994 SC 2179]. At that time laws placed in the Ninth Schedule were completely immune from judicial scrutiny. This understanding changed with I.R. Coehlo v State of Tamil Nadu [AIR 2007 SC 861] which held placing a law in the Ninth Schedule could not bar challenges for fundamental rights violations. 

Did that affect the fate of COFEPOSA? The Supreme Court in Dropti Devi v Union of India [(2012) 7 SCC 499] held that this didn't matter. It noted that as the validity of the COFEPOSA had been upheld once, the change brought by I.R. Coelho would not allow another challenge. Still, the Court went ahead to address the merits in the decision, only to bunk the arguments that the COFEPOSA violated Articles 19, 21 and 22. The economic harm that the COFEPOSA purportedly addresses was seen as a measure to safeguard the security of India by the Court.   

State Laws Authorising Preventive Detention
The vast majority of State laws greatly resemble each other - in both substance and in name - and address purported anti-social elements such as Goondas and Bootleggers. Amnesty India has put up a useful resource listing these laws and their objectives which means I can jump right away to the more recent developments on this front. I refer to the amendments to preventive detention laws brought to address video piracy and digital offenders. This was done by Karnataka most recently, giving us the atrociously titled Karnataka Prevention of Dangerous Activities of Acid Attackers, Bootleggers, Depredator of Environment, Digital Offenders, Drug Offenders, Gamblers, Goondas, Immoral Traffic Offenders, Land Grabbers, Money Launderers, Sexual Predators and Video or Audio Pirates Act 1985. The problems posed by such amendments by states have been discussed a fair bit already (see here, here and here) and has been considered once by the Madras High Court in 2005. Supplementing those critiques, I argue that these extensions are illegal for the laws do not pass the test posed by Articles 19, 21 and 22. The development of due process would suggest Article 21 poses an important test to the validity of these laws.

Conclusion
The lack of attention to preventive detention legislation in India remains surprising. Especially at at time when there is renewed attention to the expanding scope of detention without trial across the globe. The judicial approval of these statutes has stemmed debate to a certain extent, and has consequently resulted in emboldening states to continually expand preventive detention laws. While preventive action in itself is not a problem, Indian laws (both federal and state laws) display a glaring lack of proportionality in their approach. Prescribing possibly year-long detentions for potential copyright violations, when the offence itself is bailable, is patently unjustified and illegal. Looking ahead, lets see what the future holds. 

Sunday, December 11, 2016

Preventive Justice Part 2: Looking inside Pandora's Box

In the previous post, I traced the history behind Article 22 of the Indian Constitution, showing how the clause was considered to be Dr. Ambedkar's version of due process after that idea was excluded from Article 21 [India's guarantee to protect the right to life and personal liberty]. Constitutional developments since have seen the Supreme Court re-introduce the due process idea into Article 21 most famously in Maneka Gandhi's case. This, naturally, raises questions about the position of Article 22 in the panoply of rights to freedom guaranteed under the Indian Constitution. It leads me to consider the history behind the interplay between Articles 19 to 22 in this post. For this I have relied, again, on the books by Granville Austin and Mr. Seervai's commentary, and I would strongly suggest those interested in the issue to consult these sources. I then argue, that Article 22(3)(b) - excluding the right to legal representation for those preventively detained - is contrary to Article 21.

The 'Complete Code' idea - AK Gopalan and RC Cooper
A.K. Gopalan v. State of Madras [(1950) SCR 88] is one of my favourite decisions of the Supreme Court, and probably one of the most misunderstood ones too largely due to the common vilification it suffers after Maneka Gandhi. A.K. Gopalan [Communist Leader, and later Member of Parliament] was detained under the Preventive Detention Act, 1950 [a legislation hastily passed by the Nehru Government a month after the coming into force of India's Constitution to prevent release of the hundreds of persons detained under laws that would soon lapse]. Gopalan challenged the Act for violating Articles 14, 19, 21 as well being contrary to Article 22 itself. The Court upheld the validity of the Act but held Section 14 unconstitutional for violating Article 22(5) - the provision prevented even courts from accessing materials on which detention orders were based.

This post is limited to only one of the several fascinating points of discussion thrown up by Gopalan. That is the issue of Article 22 being a 'Complete Code', which means that the legality of preventive detention laws is limited to being tested only against Article 22 and not the other fundamental rights in Part III of the Constitution. The Attorney General argued this was the correct position of law. Only Mahajan, J. agreed: "I am satisfied on a review of the whole scheme of the Constitution that the intention was to make Article 22 a self-contained in respect of the laws on the subject of preventive detention." Kania, C.J., Sastri and Das, JJ. considered Articles 21 and 22 had to be read together [Kania, C.J.: "According to him [the Attorney General], Article 22 is a complete code. I am unable to accept that contention."]. Fazl Ali, J. went a step further and observed that "In my opinion, it cannot be said that Articles 19, 20, 21 and 22 do not to some extent overlap each other."

This means that the 'Complete Code' argument was rejected in Gopalan itself, the only doubts left were regarding applicability of Article 19 to preventive detention laws. Strangely, then, the majority of ten judges in R.C. Cooper [1970 SCR (3) 530, speaking through Shah, J.] held that "The majority of the Court [in Gopalan] held that Article 22 being a complete code relating to preventive detention, the validity of an order of detention must be determined strictly according to the terms and 'within the four corners of that Article'." As Mr. Seervai notes, the majority incorrectly considered the 'Complete Code' idea as being approved by Gopalan and that this was further compounded in Haradhan Saha [(1975) 3 SCC 198]. In hindsight some good came of this error. The R.C. Cooper majority upheld the view of Fazl Ali, J. and overruled Gopalan for accepting the 'Complete Code' argument [wrongly, of course]. This cleared the way for preventive detention laws to also be subjected to Article 19 challenges, together with existing tests of Articles 21 and 22. The Article 21 test was later notably strengthened in 1978 by Maneka Gandhi transplanting 'procedure established by law' with 'due process of law' without amending the text of Article 21 itself. Subsequent years saw the just, fair, and reasonable logic of Article 21 seep into preventive detention laws - Francis Coralie Mullin [AIR 1981 SC 746] an eloquent instance of the same.

Pandora's Box: Unleashing Article 21 on Article 22(3)(b)
Opening Pandora's Box is shorthand for taking decisions without appreciating the consequences. I think the analogy aptly reflects the Supreme Court's move to import 'due process' into Article 21. The interplay between the various 'rights to freedom' under Part III was based upon the specific exclusion of due process from Article 21 [discussed in the last post]. It is fair to say that the decision in Maneka Gandhi irreversibly severed Articles 19-22 from that original interpretation. Proceeding from this position, I argue that Article 21 and Article 22(3)(b) cannot coexist in the current constitutional scheme. The limited version of 'due process' guaranteed through Article 22 must give way.

Recall that Article 22(3)(b) barred persons detained under preventive detention laws from consulting and being defended by a legal practitioner of their choice. Like the rest of the preventive detention clause, this was considered necessary due to the situation prevailing at the time by Dr. Ambedkar. The Supreme Court noted its harshness but begrudgingly accepted this position. All this was because Article 22 represented the extent of due process guaranteed in the Constitution. Then the Supreme Court decided to introduce an unfettered concept of 'due process' into Article 21. This led the Court to note in Madhav Hoskot v. State of Maharashtra [(1978) 3 SCC 544] that a 'procedure established by law' entailed a right to appeal, right to counsel and imposed a duty upon the State to provide free legal aid (Krishna Iyer, J. even passed directions to that effect). How, then, does one justify the exclusion of this right to counsel through Article 22(3) to persons who perhaps are in greatest need of legal counsel? 

Five judges in A.K. Roy v. Union of India [(1982) 1 SCC 271] squarely faced this contention. Their answer was simple: detenus had not right to counsel because Article 22(3) specifically excluded it. Notice the helplessness in the opinion: "It is therefore necessary that the procedure prescribed by law for the proceedings before the Advisory Boards must be fair, just and reasonable. But then, the Constitution itself has provided a yardstick for the application of that standard, through the medium of the provisions contained in Article 22(3)(b). Howsoever much we would have liked to hold otherwise, we experience serious difficulty in taking the view that the procedure of the Advisory Boards in which the detenu is denied the right of legal representation is unfair, unjust or unreasonable. ... It is unfortunate that courts have been deprived of that choice by the express language of Article 22(3)(b) read with Article 22(1). [Emphasis mine]" What is crucial here, is the Court relying upon Article 22 itself as the yardstick to determine what is just, fair, and reasonable. I argue that this is incorrect, because after Maneka Gandhi the test of procedural fairness flows from Article 21 and not Article 22. In any event, no part of the Constitution itself remains above scrutiny, and the helplessness of the Court is akin to crocodile tears. 

Conclusion
The idea of a 'Complete Code' in Article 22 was unassumingly sustained by the Supreme Court and eventually buried by it as well. The consequences of this, however, are something that the Court continues to struggle with. While I have focused on clause (b), the retention of Article 22(3) itself despite the Supreme Court heralding a 'due process' standard is unacceptable. Looking at decisions post 1980 concerning preventive detention, it is clear that judges appreciated the problem. Successive decisions did mollify the deprivation of a right to counsel. In Nand Lal Bajaj v. State of Punjab [(1981) 4 SCC 327], the Court held that a detenu had a right to counsel where the Government was permitted to engage a lawyer to argue before the Advisory Board established under a preventive detention law. This, it reasoned, would violate Article 14 and Article 21. In A.K. Roy, after expressing its dire helplessness the Court did go ahead and hold that a person detained had a right to be assisted by a friend ["who, in truth and substance, is not a legal practitioner"] in making a representation. The Court has re-written Article 22(3) to this limited extent, but it dare not take the plunge and declare it wholly redundant.

[kudos to Gautam Bhatia for helping think this post through]     

Friday, December 2, 2016

Preventive Justice Part 1 - The History behind Article 22

India's Constitution elaborates on certain Fundamental Rights guaranteed to individuals. Some are limited as citizenship rights [Article 19] while others extend to all persons within the Union [Article 21]. As the title suggests, this post is concerned with Article 21's not-so-celebrated cousin, Article 22 [the cousin terminology is deliberate, as I will show later]. I first came across the very interesting history behind Article 22 while reading Granville Austin's Cornerstone of a Nation, and then traced the discussion in the Constituent Assembly Debates while supplementing it with some independent research. It is also discussed by Mr Seervai in his commentary on Articles 19-22 but only to the extent necessary for furthering his argument. In this post, I first look at the text of Article 22 and then the history behind its inclusion in the Constitution.

Right to Freedom - Articles 19-22
Part III of the Constitution runs from Article 12 to Article 35, but we often end up missing how the framers grouped certain rights together. Articles 19-22, for instance, are couched under Right to Freedom. One possible explanation offered is that Article 19 confers positive freedoms while Articles 20-22 confer negative freedoms by limiting what the State can do. Article 21 states that No person shall be deprived of his life or personal liberty except according to procedure established by law. 

This is followed by Article 22, which immediately tells us exactly how the State can take away this right to life and personal liberty. So, we find general protections in Articles 22(1) to (3): every person arrested must be informed of the grounds of arrest and be permitted to engage legal counsel of her choice [Article 22(1)], as well as be produced before a magistrate within 24 hours of being detained [Article 22(2)]. This, interestingly, is followed up by 22(3) which specifically takes away these rights in case of enemy aliens and persons arrested and detained under preventive detention laws. The remainder of Article 22 - clauses (4) to (7) - moves on to lay down the limits of preventive detention laws and confer certain limited rights upon detenus. Thus, ordinarily preventive detention is capped at three months unless reviewed by an Advisory Board which recommends otherwise [Article 22(4)], where the case is not of a category warranting special treatment [Article 22(7)]. Detenus have a right to be informed of the grounds behind a detention order as soon as may be [where disclosure is not contrary to public interest as per Article 22(6)], and also to make a representation against the order [Article 22(5)]. 

The majority of Article 22 appears a precision-based instrument chipping away the edges of the basic rights guaranteed by Article 21. It has frequently been attacked throughout the history of independent India, with detractors often pointing to the worst excesses of the Emergency in 1975 as indicative of the misuse Article 22 allows. What if I told you that Article 22 was introduced into the Constitution in order to prevent the worst excesses from materialising? That is the lesson we learn from history, to which I now turn.

Draft Articles 15 and 15-A and the 'Due Process' Fallout
The use of procedure established by law to safeguard the right to life under Article 21 of the Indian Constitution, as against the due process clause, is a wonderful story in itself [It is part of a separate file in the National Archives of India no less titled Article 15: Due Process of Law]. The initial Draft Article 15 (which became Article 21) contained the words due process. While the Constituent Assembly was mulling over the draft in India, Sir BN Rau - who was the Official Constitutional Adviser - had been entrusted with the task of eliciting opinion from important personalities abroad. During this time he met Justice Frankfurter, who strenuously advised him against the incorporation of the due process clause. 

Sir BN Rau considered these suggestions important enough to send a memorandum across by airmail dated 11 November 1947 (a very expensive proposition back then). He subsequently sent across his views in a formal Report in December, 1947. KM Pannikar, an Assembly Member, wrote to Sir Rau on 30 December 1947 discussing this report, and his happiness that "Munshi's [KM Munshi, member of the Assembly] due process clause has got a knockout blow from Justice Frankfurter." On 7 April 1948, Sir Rau wrote to Justice Frankfurter to inform him of the Assembly having substituted due process with procedure established by law in Article 15 of the Draft Constitution. 1948 saw fervent efforts to re-introduce due process led by KM Munshi. On 13 December, Dr. Ambedkar was asked to give his final reply on this tussle between the Legislature and the Judiciary. He is famously quoted as saying "It is rather a case where a man has to sail between a Charybdis and Scylla and I therefore would not say anything."

The stoicism in this statement does not mean that Dr. Ambedkar was simply going to accept this changed state of affairs. He supported the due process clause, and was affected by the intense criticism this withdrawal of due process drew from various circles. In September 1949, months before the conclusion of the debates, the Drafting Committee (headed by Dr. Ambedkar) cited this backdrop and introduced Article 15-A in the Assembly. This, today, is Article 22 barring some minor modifications. Article 15-A was introduced as a measure of "compensation for what was done then in passing Article 15" since removal of due process meant Article 15 conferred a carte-blanche on the executive to arrest and detain persons. Equally, existence of preventive detention as a subject on the Federal and Concurrent Lists of Business without due process protection meant the legislature could not be checked in passing oppressive legislation. These twin factors seemed to have convinced Dr. Ambedkar of the need to have express fetters placed on the possibility of arrest and detention of persons in independent India. Dr. Ambedkar spoke for the Drafting Committee when he said that "we providing for the substance of the law of 'due process' by the introduction of Article 15A". 

Conclusions and Questions
Therefore, Article 22 was in fact a measure to protect, rather than curtail, the right to life and personal liberty. Mr Seervai discusses this in his Commentary, to conclude that perhaps it would have made better sense to have the first two clauses in Article 22 as part of Article 21, making a separate Article for the exclusions. Looking at what happened subsequently, a differently drafted Article 21 might have led to a differently written judgment in Maneka Gandhi. It might have prevented the Supreme Court from going so far as to incorporating the substantive due process standard that the Constituent Assembly so painstakingly chose to avoid. Where does Maneka Gandhi leave the due process that Article 22 represented for the Constituent Assembly and Dr. Ambedkar? The Supreme Court has not considered this question fully, yet, although some seepage of Maneka jurisprudence into Article 22 has definitely resulted. In the next post we will address some of these questions arising out of the Supreme Court's engagement with Article 22 of the Constitution. 

Thursday, December 1, 2016

New Series: Preventive Justice

I recently finished two collections of essays; Regulating Deviance (Norrie et al eds., 2009), and Prevention and the Limits of the Criminal Law (Ashworth et al eds., 2013). A majority of the contributions to these volumes questioned the increased tendency of legislatures in USA, England, and Australia, to introduce legislation allowing arrest and detention of persons to prevent commission of harms. This upsets the traditional liberal argument of intervening only when there is some harm that has been caused. This is countered by governments pointing to the highly uncertain times wanton acts of terrorism have brought in. Prevention, after all, was always preached as being better than a cure.

Unsurprisingly, the horrible events of the previous decade (World Trade Centre, London Bombings, Madrid Bombings, Mumbai Train Blasts, for instance), propelled the move for harsher, stricter laws. At which point I was surprised at none of these essays referring the Indian experience, for the Indian Constitution since its inception legalised preventive detention and a withdrawal of rights for those so detained. Such a constitutional denial of liberty in Article 22 sits right next to the clause guaranteeing the right to life. Yet, little discussion is evoked by having this clause today. One might say that India is thoroughly normalised to preventive detention being part of the bargain. 

This new series on Preventive Justice in India is my effort to help spur some discussion on the limits of criminal law in India. Preventive Justice is an extremely populated field in India and the first set of posts will cover the constitutional text and statutory avatars will only come in later. Similar to how this blog earlier covered some issues serially, the a thorough engagement with the text will be followed by discussing how the Supreme Court has fashioned the limits of that text. The next post will re-live the very interesting history behind Article 22 of the Indian Constitution.